Bayside Supper Club
Located in the picturesque surroundings of Beaver Dam Lake, Bayside Supper Club at W9231 County Rd G, Beaver Dam, WI 53916, offers a refreshing take on the classic supper club experience. The cozy and inviting atmosphere, complemented by stunning lake views, makes it an ideal destination for both locals and visitors. Whether you're in the mood for a casual meal or celebrating a special occasion, Bayside provides an excellent dining experience that combines traditional comfort food with modern service.
A Relaxed yet Elegant Dining Experience
Bayside Supper Club is designed with comfort and elegance in mind. The restaurant offers a casual yet classy environment, with large windows showcasing breathtaking views of Beaver Dam Lake. The combination of a relaxed setting and sophisticated service ensures a memorable dining experience for everyone. It's the kind of place where you can enjoy a hearty meal with family, friends, or colleagues, all while taking in the peaceful lakeside ambiance.
Versatile Dining Services for Every Occasion
One of the standout features of Bayside Supper Club is the wide array of services it offers, making it a great choice for various dining preferences. The restaurant accommodates both casual diners and larger groups with ease. It's wheelchair accessible, ensuring that everyone can enjoy the venue, and it also accepts credit cards, so paying is hassle-free. The takeout and delivery options cater to those who prefer to enjoy a meal at home, while reservations are available for those who want to secure a table for a special night out.
For those who love a good deal, Bayside Supper Club regularly offers happy hour specials, making it an excellent spot to unwind after a long day. The full bar provides an extensive selection of beverages, and there's always free Wi-Fi available for customers who need to stay connected. Families and groups will appreciate the catering service and the kid-friendly options available on the menu.
A Culinary Experience to Savor
The menu at Bayside Supper Club offers a delightful range of dishes that cater to a variety of tastes. While the restaurant doesn’t follow the typical supper club format with relish trays, it does offer plenty of food for the money, according to several happy customers. Signature items include a well-loved Friday night fish fry, which is complemented by a buffet offering an array of seafood, pasta, and more. Guests rave about the quality and freshness of the food, with many particularly enjoying the tender prime rib and crispy breaded shrimp.
Positive Customer Experiences
Guests frequently highlight the outstanding service and welcoming atmosphere at Bayside Supper Club. Nicholas B. shares his appreciation for the service, especially on busy Friday nights when the restaurant offers its popular fish fry and buffet. He notes that while it's not the traditional supper club, the food and setting more than make up for it. The spacious windows provide a scenic view of the lake, adding to the overall charm of the dining experience.
Dale A. also commended the restaurant for its exceptional customer service, especially when his party arrived late, just before closing time. Despite the timing, the staff ensured that they had a fantastic meal, continuing to refresh the buffet selections even though they were the last guests of the night. The value for money, with food, drinks, and a tip for four people totaling just $33.50, was another highlight of the experience.
For those who love a good buffet, Lynn B. also raves about the tender prime rib and large breaded shrimp served at Bayside Supper Club. Her group of seven all enjoyed the diverse offerings and appreciated the friendly service, making it an all-around positive dining experience.
Reviews
The first impression is how nice the staff is. This is an old-school super club buffet. Nice selection of fish shrimp and pasta. We arrived late...half hour before closing...No problem...we were seated and enjoyed a great dinner. They even kept refreshing the selections even though our party was the only partakers. Cost for four with food, bar drinks, and tip was $33.50 @ this was a Great night and we will be back to try the Sunday Brunch.
Great tender prime-rib excellent large breaded shrimp, scenic view of lake, kind friendly waitress. All 7 of us loved the buffet and the scenery.
Met some friends here on a Saturday night, Beaver Dam was in the middle for us. None of us had been here before. We arrived about 6pm and the place was very quiet. We had a few drinks at the bar before sitting down to our table. The Hostess (owner?) was very nice to us, and our server, Pam, was excellent and fun. They offered a prime rib buffet that my husband enjoyed. I wasn't paying much attention, but I noticed he had (thin) prime rib, chicken fingers, shrimp, cheesy potatoes......All dinners came with the salad bar, which noy many people have anymore. Everything there was fresh, crisp and cold. It had your standard issue salad and toppings, French, Ranch and an Italian dressing, and about four mayonaise type salads. My ribeye had a great flavor and was tender, served with a baked potato. The other two had a filet and the prime rib. Everyone enjoyed their food, and we even had a view of the pelicans on the lake that night. We had made reservations, but the place was very empty. I believe they were closing early for a private event as we were leaving. We likely won't return only because we are not from in town, but I will definitely recommend it to others.
The food is always great, I absolutely love the Friday night fish/chicken buffet. Constantly adding fresh food, good quality. The service is great and friendly.
Great service. Friday night fish fry and buffet. Not the standard "supper club" with the relish tray, etc. but plenty of food for the money. Lovely setting on Beaver Dam Lake featured through large windows. Full bar while waiting for a table which you can expect on Friday nights.